FDA Crackdown on the Stem Cell Wild West

By /

stem cell clinic crackdown

This week, the FDA announced that it was sending a warning letter to US Stem Cell in Florida and a California venture known as Stem Immune, linked to the Cell Surgical Network. What do both of these clinics have in common? They both use a product called stromal vascular fraction (SVF) obtained from fat. The FDA has said for some time that this product was a cell drug and not covered under their practice of medicine exemption. I suspect we’ll see more letters in the coming weeks. This crackdown is needed—let me explain.

The Stem Cell Wild West

Having done this work since 2005, I’ve seen the stem cell Wild West begin. At first, it was just a physician colleague who I knew had made up his outcome data from thin air. Later it was the entry of professional business people who saw an opportunity. Finally, it was the rise of the wide mass-media push by chiropractic clinics. There were many opportunities along the way for the promise of regenerative medicine to be self-regulated by physicians, but that never happened. In the absence of medicine regulating itself, someone always steps in to regulate. Be it the FDA, the civil court system, medical boards, or professional organizations.

Way back in 2008, we helped form the International Cellular Medicine Society (ICMS) as a way to self-regulate. The goal was to have all physicians follow strict guidelines on the adoption of treating new diseases with stem cells and track the outcomes of every patient. The problem, in the end, was that the physicians involved didn’t want regulation. They wanted to be able to treat every disease without any impediment or requirement that data be collected. So I moved on from ICMS and focused instead on building Interventional Orthopedics instead.

The First Step Toward an Out-of-Control Industry: The Magic-Fat-Stem-Cell-Pixie-Dust Clinic

Since about 2012, things went from physicians trying new and novel stem cell therapies in select patients to out of control. Much of that initial switch happened because of adipose stromal vascular fraction (SVF) clinics offering to treat every incurable disease known to man. These providers viewed stem cells not as a tool that needed to be carefully deployed in select circumstances, but more as magic pixie dust to be widely sprinkled everywhere. So while we in orthopedic care would begin with simpler treatments, like platelet rich plasma, and only sometimes use stem cells, the fat-stem-cell crowd would begin with magic stem cells injected intravenously and then injected blindly somewhere else. In addition, while in orthopedic care we would wring our hands over who was a good or poor candidate, the magic-fat-stem-cell crowd would consider everyone a candidate. While we would track our patients in registries and report our unfiltered outcomes, the magic-fat crowd would just treat, often while collecting no or minimal data.

The Recent Crackdown

First, the FDA has been telegraphing its punches on fat stem cells since 2011–12. This culminated in draft guidances that were issued in 2014. Last year this came to a head with a public commentary event. All throughout, the FDA has sent a steady stream of Warning Letters to various physicians using fat stem cells.

The recent FDA crackdown was focused on the two groups using fat stem cells. One was US Stem Cell in Sunrise, Florida, and the other was Cell Surgical Network based out of Los Angeles. I had also blogged on both groups starting to culture expand stem cells, another clear drug product without approval (see blog on CSN/American Cryostem and US Stem Cell).

What Is the FDA Action Really About?

The FDA has long pursued a “line in the sand” approach to regulating stem cells. If the cells are minimally manipulated (meaning that the processing has fewer steps), then they are not regulated as drugs. If the cells are from the same patient and part of the same surgical procedure, then they are exempt from FDA regulation under 21 CFR 1271.15(b). Our Regenexx procedures using bone marrow concentrate fit squarely on this side of the line. On the other hand, if the processing is more extensive, then the cells are deemed “more than minimally manipulated” and, as such, are considered cell drugs regulated by FDA under section 351. The recent news stories all pertain to cells that are more than minimally manipulated.

As a company, we have known for some time that these fat-based stem cell products that require extensive lab processing are cell drugs. However, the clinics that have used these products have maintained that they are not drugs. Obviously, with the recent FDA crackdown, there is overwhelming evidence that the FDA considers these regenerative-medicine products made from fat as cellular drugs that are not exempt from regulation and that require full FDA approval involving extensive clinical trials.

The Tip of the Proverbial Iceberg

While the fat-stem-cell crowd has needed reining in for some time, the newest version of the “Stem Cell Wild West” is even worse than the last. Chiropractic groups have gotten their teeth into this industry to offer dead amniotic and cord blood tissue as a “stem cell” therapy. Based on all of the tests I have seen so far showing that these products have no living cells, this is likely massive consumer fraud on a grand scale, stretching itself to every major city newspaper with full-page ads offering the magic of “stem cells.” On the FDA side, the claims of live cells in amniotic and cord tissue make these 351 cell drugs that require full FDA clinical trials before sale or marketing (see video below), which none of these companies have. So, hopefully, the FDA has noticed these full-page ads for “stem cell” products it never approved as such.

The upshot? It is our sincerest hope that the new FDA task force on stem cell therapy “bad actors” continues to clean up the Stem Cell Wild West. While taking out the magic-fat-stem-cell-clinic crowd is a good start, the next big thing is chiropractors injecting dead tissue and claiming it’s an FDA-approved stem cell product!

Get health and wellness information from a trusted source.

By submitting the form, you are agreeing that you read and consent to our Privacy Policy. We may also contact you via email, phone, and other electronic means to communicate information about our products and services. We do not sell, or share your information to third party vendors.

Category: Latest News

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

6 thoughts on “FDA Crackdown on the Stem Cell Wild West

  1. Scott Massey

    Have you looked at the new FDA approved Cryotherapy Ablation for long term pain.
    It is for nerve ablation and triggers Wallerian Degeneration which seems to reboot the synapses after inhibition of the signaling process. Trying to evaluate it from an Ortho 2.0 perspective looking at causation and if this fits the mantra of Stability, Articulation, Neuro Muscular and Symmetry. Thanks for the on going information, your research has helped tremendously in developing a serious approach to regenerative medicine.

    1. Regenexx Team Post author

      Thanks! To answer your question on Cryotherapy Ablation, if it kills the nerve (which is what ablation is), not sure I care if it’s hot or cold, it’s still a dead nerve.

  2. sandy gray

    My chiropractor …Dr Robert Biddle is the 1 that put me on to Regenexx,,,,,,,,,Just NEED the damn INS companies to approve this expensive procedure !! Also my Husbands Orthopedic Dr told him to try it for his hip or knee …….Now that is saying alot !!…..How can we get this approved …Im calling INS on my end!!……….to me its a win win ….no brainer !! except for Dr’s …….but the INS ppl ……..can save thousands !

    1. Regenexx Team Post author

      Sandy Gray,
      Sounds like Dr. Biddle and your Ortho really care about you and your husband – I’d keep them! Please do speak to your Insurance company, you never know…

  3. Ron

    When is the stem cell therapy application for stroke patients available tentatively? I’m getting desperate now.

    1. Regenexx Team

      Hi Ron,
      There is a great deal of research going on, but unfortunately, we don’t have that information. But, if we hear of something reputable, we will let you know.

Is Regenexx Right For You?

Request a free Regenexx Info Packet


Learn about the #1 Stem Cell & Platelet Procedures for treating arthritis, common joint injuries & spine pain.

Join a Webinar


Get fresh updates and insights from Regenexx delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscribe to the Blog


9035 Wadsworth Pkwy #1000
Westminster, CO 80021


Copyright © Regenexx 2020. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy

*DISCLAIMER: Like all medical procedures, Regenexx® Procedures have a success and failure rate. Patient reviews and testimonials on this site should not be interpreted as a statement on the effectiveness of our treatments for anyone else.

Providers listed on the Regenexx website are for informational purposes only and are not a recommendation from Regenexx for a specific provider or a guarantee of the outcome of any treatment you receive.