Are Fat Injections in Knee Joints Stem Cell Procedures?
Physicians today, at a minimum, need to be able to define what a stem cell procedure really is and need to be able to assure their patients that their stem cell procedure likely works through the action of stem cells. Unfortunately, either unknowingly or deceptively, there are many procedures being performed that are called stem cell therapy that really aren’t. Examples include procedures using amniotic “stem cells,” PRP and other blood products, and the feature of this post—fat grafts, which is what many fat injections in knee joints and other joints actually are.
Today I am going to talk about why a fat graft is not a stem cell procedure. The short video above contains images and other information that will enhance your understanding, so be sure to watch the video as well.
The first question you might be asking is, What is a fat graft? So let’s start there.
What Is a Fat Graft?
In their raw forms, fat stem cells are much different from bone marrow stem cells in that fat stem cells are imprisoned inside a collagen matrix. On the other hand, bone marrow stem cells, once removed from the body via an aspiration, are free floating in a mix of cells.
Fat is most commonly harvested from the body via a liposuction. Following the liposuction, the fat can then centrifuged in a machine to separate it into layers. This leaves oil on the top, structural fat in the middle, and a water layer filled with red blood cells on the bottom. Once the top and bottom fractions are removed, what’s left is the structural fat.
At this point, that structural fat is often called a fat graft. While the fat graft does house stem cells inside the collagen matrix, those stem cells are trapped. The fat stem cells, according to our lab research, are imprisoned inside that collagen matrix (see the video images explaining the collagen matrix and how fat is imprisoned there).
I recently came across a physician reporting that by using a simple bedside fat centrifuge and a plastic kit, he was able to get two-thirds of a million viable stem cells per ml of fat. Knowing the machine he reported using, it’s almost impossible that he is getting any viable stem cells at all from this device, let alone 2/3rds of a million mesenchymal or other stem cells. Why?
SVF vs. a Fat Graft
Regrettably, most doctors using stem cells today learned what they know from a weekend course and don’t have a deep knowledge of the topic. For example, I still find that most don’t understand the difference between a fat graft and Stromal Vascular Fraction (SVF). They are quite different. For example, one has stem cells imprisoned in collagen that are likely not useful to the patient and the other has stem cells that have been broken out of their collagen jail cells. One is fully FDA compliant and the other is currently illegal to use in the U.S.
Are Fat Stem Cells Released From Their Fat Graft Prison for Fat Injections in Knee Joints?
If we could release the stem cells from the collagen matrix, then they could go to work. But can we release them, and, if so, how? Technically, yes, the fat stem cells can be released from a fat graft. You can dissolve away the collagen prison that is trapping the fat stem cells with an enzyme, like collagenase. This mix is then centrifuged and washed, and, finally, among many other cells, you’ll find the once-imprisoned stem cells now at the bottom of the tube. However, as I’ve mentioned before, there’s a big and very serious problem with this kind of fat stem cell processing: it’s illegal per current US law because the FDA considers it an illegally produced drug!
To get around the legal issues, many clinics just liposuction the fat and centrifuge it (fat graft) and/or chop it all up very finely and inject it and, in either case, they often either unknowingly or deceptively, call the fat injections in knee joints or other joints, a stem cell procedure.
Our Own Research on Chopped-Up Fat
In our advanced research lab, we’ve tested all of this exhaustively, and we’ve never been able to get any significant number of viable stem cells using any of the various methods used to chop up fat. In one research sample, you’ll see in the video, the fat was chopped up so finely that it appears to be an emulsified liquid. However, though it looks like it may have liberated cells, it is really just large microscopic chunks of fat with stem cells still imprisoned in the collagen matrix. In other words, no stem cells were released from their collagen prison cells.
Hence, regardless of how fine we chop the fat or macerate it with balls, we can’t call chopped-up fat a stem-cell therapy. At the very least, physicians must understand and agree that significant quantities of viable stem cells must be freely available to the body for any process to be called a stem cell procedure, and all physicians using stem cell therapy must understand and agree on its definition in order to protect consumers.
The upshot? So is a legal procedure that uses liposuctioned fat run through a centrifuge to do fat injections in knee joints and other joints a stem cell procedure? Absolutely not; it’s a fat graft procedure where stem cells are imprisoned in a collagen matrix. Is a procedure that legally processes the fat by chopping it up a stem cell procedure? Absolutely not; it’s a microscopic-chunks-of-fat procedure that still doesn’t release the stem cells from their collagen prisons. In fact, the only real fat based stem cell procedure is SVF, but regrettably, the FDA considers that illegal to use in patients.